‘Tis the season to eat, drink, and be merry! If you’re feeling the holiday spirit, know that local St. Augustine bars are serving up all sorts of holiday spirits as well to match your holly jolly vibe. After all, with Nights of Lights all around, you know this town is full of cheer. Here’s where to sip festive Christmas cocktails in St. Augustine. 

And of course, you can find lots of Christmas cocktails in Orlando too.

Festive Christmas Cocktails in St. Augustine

Barley Republic

48 Spanish St., St. Augustine | (904) 547-2023

Are you on Santa’s naughty or nice list? Either way, the “Naughty Aussie” is a nice addition to Barley Republic’s Late Risers’ brunch menu. This daytime cocktail features Cruzan Vanilla Rum, 5 Farms Irish Cream, vanilla syrup, and Kookaburra cold brew. 

Exterior of Barley Republic St. Augustine Bar and Restaurant
Exterior of Barley Republic St. Augustine – image by Maria DiCicco

Boat Drinks

56 St. George St., St. Augustine | (904) 274-0094

The Boat Drinks crew understands that sometimes you need a drink to get you through the holidays. This fun bar goes all out with its “Sunburnt Santa” celebration, featuring special edition holiday beverages. Rumor has it that the guy in the big red suit likes “Cookies for Santa,” a sweet taste of rye whiskey, amaretto cookie, lemon and mint.

His Misses may prefer “Ms. Claus Got Her Groove Back,” a vodka concoction with mango White Claw, lime, cranberry and Curacao. Rudolph likely gravitates to the “Fruitcake Old Fashioned,” a mix of apple brandy, Agricole Rhum, black cherry, vanilla, candied citrus and winter spices.

Fruitcake Old Fashioned from Boat Drinks St. Augustine – @boatdrinksbar

Whereas the elves could toss back the “North Pole Vice,” featuring candy cane-infused frozen mojito with pina colada flare. 

Catch 27 

40 Charlotte St., St. Augustine | (904) 217-3542

If you’re more fruit cake than peppermint patty, know that you can stick to your preferred flavor profile while still toasting the town with holiday spirit. It may be called the Lonely Hearts Club, but we promise that this is a great cocktail companion. It is Chawar agave spirit, Salers Aperitif, sliced strawberry, and peppercorn cordial… creating a delicate red and green presentation but with lighter flavor notes. 

Chatsworth Publick House

10 Marine St., St. Augustine | (904) 615-1815

Move over Christmas cookies… Chatsworth famously tops some of its cocktails with donuts! For the holidays, the bar menu will highlight seasonal martinis, including a Peppermint Martini and Salted Caramel Martini. Plus, ideal for a nightcap following a St. Augustine Nights of Lights tour, Chatsworth is a go-to for Bailey’s and coffee. 

FYI, take a photo with Mrs. Claus at the Chatsworth Pub (who may or may not be a bartender) with your drink of choice. Then tag Chatsworth when posting your selfie on social media to be entered for a $50 e-giftcard to use at the restaurant on a later date. 

Columbia Restaurant

98 St. George St., St. Augustine | (904) 824-3341

Columbia Restaurant, Florida’s oldest dining establishment dating back to 1905, is praised for its house-made sangria. And while a glass or pitcher of Tinto (red) or Blanco (white) sangria may remain your go-to when dining at Columbia, branch out to try the Jalisco Winter.

This Christmasy cocktail features private-barrel Maestro Dobel Añejo Tequila with St. George Spiced Pear Liqueur and a touch of fresh lemon juice.

Entrance to Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine
Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine – image by @columbiarestaurant

Ice Plant Bar

110 Riberia St., St. Augustine | (904) 829-6553

To sip on a drink that’s the exact same shade of green as The Grinch, order the La Reina Del Pacifico at Ice Plant Bar. This drink combines tequila, mint, basil, arugula, snap pea, wasabi, fresh lemon juice and black pepper.

Plus, transitioning from green to red, cranberry fans will love the Valley of the Dolls, composed of vodka, Beauchant orange liqueur, cranberry, orange, lemon, and Jamaican bitters. 

people sitting at the Ice Plant Bar in St. Augustine
Ice Plant Bar St. Augustine – image by Maria DiCicco

Llama Restaurant

415 Anastasia Blvd., St. St. Augustine | (904) 819-1760

Mimosas are often associated with brunch but Llama Restaurant understands that mimosas pair well with any meal, including dinner.

During the holiday season, Llama will continue to offer its standard mimosa list featuring five unique champagne and juice blends. Additionally, it’ll introduce a passionfruit and lavender mimosa with edible glitter in honor of the glitzy glow associated with St. Augustine Nights of Lights

Mellow Mushroom

Multiple Locations 

As this funky pizza chain says, “mellow is a state of mind, a culture, a way of being.” Enhance that mellow status with one of their signature Liquid Karma Cocktails or The Blitzen, Mellow Mushroom’s festive Christmas cocktail. The Blitzen features Flor de Caña 7-year-aged Rum, St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur and pomegranate flavors. 

Prohibition Kitchen 

119 St. George St., Saint Augustine | (904) 209-5704 

“Mele Kalikimaka is the thing to say on a bright Hawaiian Christmas day…” If this Bing Crosby song gets stuck in your head too, clear your thoughts with a Hawaiian lei inspired Christmas cocktail called Hibiscus Spritz. It’s made with elderflower, sparkling wine, lemon, simple syrup, mint and, of course, hibiscus.

You can also warm up on a rare chilly night in St. Augustine with a Classic Hot Chocolate.

Classic Hot Chocolate from Prohibition Kitchen St Augustine
Classic Hot Chocolate from Prohibition Kitchen St Augustine – @prohibition_kitchen

San Sebastian Winery

157 King St., St. Augustine | (904) 826-1594

To drink up St. Augustine’s dazzling holiday light display and more, head to The Cellar Upstairs Bar at San Sebastian Winery. As you tune into eclectic live music, appreciate the flavorful notes of a Hot Mulled Wine. It features the full-fruit flavor of San Sebastian’s Vintners Red, balanced with mulling spices of cinnamon, cloves and orange peel.

Tini Martini Bar

24 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine | (904) 829-0928

Located within the Casablanca Inn, step into an adorably decorated space complete with a Christmas tree, stockings, a (big) Little Drummer Boy, and, as a nod to The Christmas Story movie, a leg lamp!

This place can make any kind of martini, in addition to signature cocktails and wines. Since we won’t have a White Christmas here in St. Augustine, channel that wonderful winter feeling with a White Chocolate Espresso, made with Van Gogh Expresso vodka, white creme de cocoa, and Godiva White Chocolate Liqueur. 

Where to Find More Festive Christmas Cocktails in St. Augustine